United Japan Pro Wrestling

World Wrestling Entertainment

• 1 WWE Universal Championship

• 2 NXT Championship

• 2 WWE Intercontinental Championship

• 1 WWE United States Championship

• 3 WWE Raw/World Tag Team Championship (2 with Damian Priest, 1 with JD McDonagh)

• 2 WWE SmackDown Tag Team Championship (with Damian Priest)

• 1 NXT Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic (2015) (with Samoa Joe)

New Japan Pro Wrestling

• 3 IWGP Junior Heavyweight Championship

• 6 IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Championship (4 with Ryusuke Taguchi, 2 with Minoru Tanaka)

• 2 NJPW Best of the Super Juniors (2010, 2013)

American Wrestling Roadshow

• 1 Wrestling.Ie Championship

Consejo Mundial de Lucha Libre

• 1 NWA World Historic Middleweight Championship

Insane Championship Wrestling

• 1 ICW Zero-G Championship

NWA UK Hammerlock

• 2 NWA British Commonwealth Heavyweight Championship

Revolution Pro Wrestling

• 1 British Cruiserweight Championship

Other Accomplishments

• WWE Grand Slam Champion

• WWE Slammy Award - Faction of the Year (2024 - as member of The Judgement Day)

• NXT Championship #1 Contender's Tournament Winner (2015)

• NXT Year-End Award - Overall Competitor of the Year (2015)

• NXT Year-End Award - Male Competitor of the Year (2015)

• NXT Year-End Award - Match of the Year (2020 - vs. Kyle O'Reilly at NXT TakeOver 31)

• NJPW J Sports Crown Openweight 6 Man Tag Tournament Winner (2010, 2011 - with Ryusuke Taguchi & Hirooki Goto)

• Tokyo Sports' Best Bout Award Winner (2010 - with Ryusuke Taguchi vs. Kenny Omega & Kota Ibushi, 11/10)

• Kaientai Dojo's Best Tag Team Match Award (2010 - with Ryusuke Taguchi vs. Makoto Oishi & Shiori Asahi, 17/04)

• PWI Faction of the Year (2023 - with The Judgment Day)

• 3° in PWI 500 (2016)

• 8° in PWI Tag Team 100 (2023 – with Damian Priest & Dominik Mysterio)

• WON Most Underrated (2018)

Tag Teams & Stables

• The Judgment Day - Damian Priest, Rhea Ripley, JD McDonagh, Dominik Mysterio, Carlito, Liv Morgan, Raquel Rodriguez ( June 6, 2022 - Present)

• AJ Styles & Finn Bálor - AJ Styles ( May 2, 2022 - June 5, 2022)

• Finn Bálor & Samoa Joe - Samoa Joe ( September 9, 2015 - October 7, 2015)

• Bullet Club - Karl Anderson, Luke / Doc Gallows, Matt Jackson, Nick Jackson , Rey Bucanero, El Terrible, La Comandante ( May 3, 2013 - April 6, 2014)

• Apollo 55 - Ryusuke Taguchi ( January 30, 2009 - April 7, 2013)

• RISE - Hirooki Goto, Albert / Tensai / Matt Bloom, Milano Collection A.T., Shinsuke Nakamura, Minoru Tanaka , Rick Fuller ( November 23, 2007 - March 19, 2009)

• C.T.U - Gedo, Hirooki Goto, Jado, Jushin Thunder Liger, Minoru Tanaka ( November 26, 2006 - August 26, 2007)

• Team Ireland - Paul Tracey ( October 18, 2002 - October 6, 2005)